Race and Class: Privilege across class lines (Double Participation)

Published September 29, 2014 by djlwsu

Explaining White Privilege to a Broke White Person

(This was a much nicer camper setup than the one we had.)

Gina Crosley-Corcoran grew up in the type of poverty Americans like to pretend doesn’t exist, so it was hard for her to believe she had any privilege. 

Years ago, some feminist on the internet told me I was “Privileged.”

“THE FUCK!?!?” I said.

I came from the kind of Poor that people don’t want to believe still exists in this country. Have you ever spent a frigid northern Illinois winter without heat or running water? I have. At twelve years old, were you making ramen noodles in a coffee maker with water you fetched from a public bathroom? I was. Have you ever lived in a camper year round and used a random relative’s apartment as your mailing address? We did. Did you attend so many different elementary schools that you can only remember a quarter of their names? Welcome to my childhood.

So when that feminist told me I had “white privilege,” I told her that my white skin didn’t do shit to prevent me from experiencing poverty. Then, like any good, educated feminist would, she directed me to Peggy McIntosh’s 1988 now-famous piece, “White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack.”

After one reads McIntosh’s powerful essay, it’s impossible to deny that being born with white skin in America affords people certain unearned privileges in life that people of another skin color simple are not afforded. For example:

“I can turn on the television or open to the front page of the paper and see people of my race widely represented.”

“When I am told about our national heritage or about “civilization,” I am shown that people of my color made it what it is.”

“If a traffic cop pulls me over or if the IRS audits my tax return, I can be sure I haven’t been singled out because of my race.”

“I can if I wish arrange to be in the company of people of my race most of the time.”

If you read through the rest of the list, you can see how white people and people of color experience the world in two very different ways. BUT LISTEN: This is not said to make white people feel guilty about their privilege. It’s not your fault you were born with white skin and experience these privileges. BUT, whether you realize it or not, you DO benefit from it, and it IS your fault if you don’t maintain awareness of that fact.

I do understand McIntosh’s essay may rub some people the wrong way. There are several points on the list that I felt spoke more to the author’s status as a Middle Class person than a White Person. For example:

“If I should need to move, I can be pretty sure of renting or purchasing housing in an area, which I can afford and in which I would want to live.”

“I can be pretty sure that my neighbors in such a location will be neutral or pleasant to me.”

“I can go shopping alone most of the time, pretty well assured that I will not be followed or harassed.”

“If I want to, I can be pretty sure of finding a publisher for this piece on white privilege.”

And there are so many more points in the essay where the word “race” could be substituted for the word “class” which would ultimately paint a very different picture. That is why I had such a hard time identifying with this essay for so long. When I first wrote about White Privilege years ago, I demanded to know why this White Woman felt that my experiences were the same as hers when no, my family most certainly could not rent housing “in an area which we could afford and want to live.”

And no, I couldn’t go shopping without fear in our low income neighborhoods.

The idea that any ol’ white person can find a publisher for a piece is most certainly a symptom of class privilege. Having come from a family of people who didn’t even graduate high school, who knew not a single academic or intellectual person, it would never occur to me to assume that I could be published. It is an absolute freak anomaly that I’m in graduate school considering not one person on either side of my family has a college degree. And it took me until my thirties to ever believe that someone from my stock could achieve such a thing. Poverty colors nearly everything about your perspective on opportunities for advancement in life. Middle class, educated people assume that anyone can achieve their goals if they work hard enough. Folks steeped in poverty rarely see a life past working at the gas station, making the rent on their trailer, and self-medicating with cigarettes and prescription drugs until they die of a heart attack. (I’ve just described one whole side of my family and the life I assumed I’d be living before I lucked out of it.)

…recognizing Privilege doesn’t mean suffering guilt or shame for your lot in life.

I, maybe more than most people, can completely understand why broke white folks get pissed when the word “Privilege” is thrown around. As a child, I was constantly discriminated against because of my poverty and those wounds still run very deep. But luckily my college education introduced me to a more nuanced concept of Privilege; the term Intersectionality. The concept of Intersectionality recognizes that people can be privileged in some ways and definitely not privileged in others. There are many different types of privilege, not just skin color privilege, that impact the way people can move through the world or are discriminated against. These are all things you are born into, not things you earned, that afford you opportunities others may not have. For example:

Citizenship – Simply being born in this country affords you certain privileges non-citizens will never access.

Class – Being born into a financially stable family can help guarantee your health, happiness, safety, education, intelligence, and future opportunities.

Sexual Orientation – By being born straight, every state in this country affords you privileges that non-straight folks have to fight the Supreme Court for.

Sex – By being born male, you can assume that you can walk through a parking garage without worrying you’ll be raped and that a defense attorney will then blame it on what you were wearing.

Ability – By being born able bodied, you probably don’t have to plan your life around handicap access, braille, or other special needs.

Gender – By being born cisgendered, you aren’t worried that the restroom or locker room you use will invoke public outrage.

♦◊♦

As you can see, belonging to one or more category of Privilege, especially being a Straight White Middle Class Able-Bodied Male, can be like winning a lottery you didn’t even know you were playing. But this is not to imply that any form of privilege is exactly the same as another or that people lacking in one area of privilege understand what it’s like to be lacking in other areas. Race discrimination is not equal to Sex Discrimination and so forth.

And listen, recognizing Privilege doesn’t mean suffering guilt or shame for your lot in life. Nobody’s saying that Straight White Middle Class Able-Bodied Males are all a bunch of assholes who don’t work hard for what they have. Recognizing Privilege simply means being aware that some people have to work much harder just to experience the things you take for granted (if they ever can experience them at all.)

I know now that I AM Privileged in many ways. I am Privileged as a natural born white citizen. I am privileged as a cis-gendered woman. I am privileged as an able-bodied person. I am privileged that my first language is also our national language, and that I was born with an intellect and ambition that pulled me out of the poverty I was otherwise destined for. I was privileged to be able to marry my way “up” by partnering with a Privileged middle-class educated male who fully expected me to earn a college degree.

There are a million ways I experience Privilege, and some that I certainly don’t. But thankfully, Intersectionality allows us to examine these varying dimensions and degrees of discrimination while raising awareness of the results of multiple systems of oppression at work.

Tell me, are you a White Person made uncomfortable by the term “White Privilege?” Does a more nuanced approach help you see your own Privilege more clearly?

—-

What We Aren’t Talking About When We Talk About ‘White Privilege’

May 24, 2012

By Theresa Warburton and Joshua Cerretti

We’re white feminists. We aren’t white just because our ancestors were mostly European. We are white because we regularly experience being identified as such by individuals and institutions that systematically favor those who appear white over those who don’t. We aren’t feminists just because we have degrees and teach in Gender and Women’s Studies. We are feminists because we are committed to dismantling the structures that systematically favor men over women, heterosexuals over non-heterosexuals, the rich over the poor, and, amongst many other oppressions, white people over people of color.

In order to address that oppression, we try to get people to talk frankly about race – never an easy task in a cultural paradigm that has been described as ‘colorblind racism,’ ‘race-evasive,’ and ‘racism without racists.’  Talking frankly about race doesn’t just mean pointing out hostile attitudes and narrow stereotypes based on race, though; it also means being honest about our own experiences as raced beings. It means talking about how we are embedded in racial systems, not disembodied and dispassionate viewers of them. It also means talking about how being against racism doesn’t mean that we don’t say and do racist things.

It means we need to have a conversation about white privilege.

But before we have that conversation, maybe we need to be clearer about what we talk about when we talk about white privilege—or, maybe what we really need to talk about is what we AREN’T talking about when we talk about white privilege.

What we mean is this: we’ve been doing this long enough to recognize some trends, first in our own reactions to being called out on our privilege and second, to see those reactions play out elsewhere. Therefore, we want to lay out some no-nonsense caveats that we hope can pre-empt some of these reactions, or at least make it so that we can move forward more quickly without having to keep copying and posting pieces of ‘Derailing for Dummies’ to get down to the stuff that lies beyond the defensive reactions.

So, let’s be clear. When we say that we/you have ‘white privilege’:

1. We don’t mean that we/you are intentionally acting in a bigoted way

2. We don’t mean that our/your biology is our/your destiny

3. We don’t mean that we/you aren’t oppressed in some other way

In the simplest way, recognizing one’s privilege is about recognizing that what you think, say, and do is affected by the fact that you have been and continue to be afforded certain unearned privileges on the basis of one or more parts of your identity. So, when you’re called out on your privilege, there’s one sure-fire tactic that you can use to keep the situation as productive as possible—LISTEN.

Chances are, the person isn’t trying to ‘out’ you as a racist, prove that you are stupid, or deny you your right to free speech. Chances are, the person is trying to get you to understand that there is a perspectiveother than your own and that your perspective is shaped by your experience and therefore cannot be expressed unilaterally or universally.

We know you didn’t ‘ask’ for privilege—but we also know that you can’t just give it up once you recognize you have it. You can’t just think really hard about it for a few hours, days, months, weeks, or even years and then one day stand up, dust yourself off, and yell ‘YES! I’m no longer privileged!’

Because of this, it’s worth acknowledging that those critical of talking about white privilege are right to say that these discussions alone aren’t going to solve the problem of white supremacy. Of course, it’s also worth acknowledging that nobody ever said they would. Rather, outing our privilege, reckoning with it, and addressing how the privileges that others experience affect us are all important elements for building the sorts of mass movements that will actually be able to challenge and overcome white supremacy, heteropatriarchy, capitalism and the numerous other forms of oppression that structure our lives.

These challenging conversations are necessary because, in the age of intensive plurality and diversity, any movement worth being part of is going to involve organizing across many forms of difference. Notice how we say ‘across’ and not ‘in spite of.’ We say that because it’s likely that most people in these movements will have at least one identity that provides systematic, unearned advantages – whiteness, maleness, heterosexuality, citizenship, able-bodiedness, etc. – and those same people will have other identities that provide systematic, unearned disadvantages. We need to recognize that the vast majority of people are both oppressed and oppressive in different ways, in different contexts, and in different moments.

Therefore, if you are on the receiving end of a question, suggestion, or rant about your white privilege, don’t get offended. Nobody’s accusing you of Klan membership, a biologically determined inability to fight injustice, or being The Man/Big Brother/Whitey/Hegemon. And nobody who’s pointing out the way privilege over-determines many of our ideas, opinions, and desires thinks that a conversation with you about privilege will end state and interpersonal violence, equalize the wealth, and get the land back into the hands of Indigenous peoples.

You’re receiving this talk about white privilege because we want to work together to rid this world of the various oppressions that make life worse for so many people. Overcoming the challenge that these forces present will require working across multiple forms of difference, and to do this we mustn’t forget that the challenges lie not in difference itself, but in the oppressions structured around difference. As Audre Lorde said so beautifully…

[…]it is not the differences between us that tear us apart, destroying the commonalities we share. Rather, it is our refusal to examine the distortions which arise form their misnaming, and from the illegitimate usage of those differences which can be made when we do not claim them nor define them for ourselves.

As feminists, we don’t want to participate in the use of oppressive force or reproduce any system that legitimates this force. As white people born in the U.S. who work at a university, we’ve benefited enormously from this very system we oppose. These contradictions will not be resolved in silence and, unless we work on recognizing and addressing them, we don’t expect for it to be easy for anyone who hasn’t shared our experiences to work with us.

We’re on a journey, a trip with a destination that we don’t expect to reach tomorrow; a journey towards understanding how experiences of privilege turn into flat tires and roadblocks on the trips we want to take away from ugly histories of oppression.

So, next time somebody invites you along for the ride, don’t wave them along—hop on.

Advertisements

12 comments on “Race and Class: Privilege across class lines (Double Participation)

  • This posting really keeps the term “stereotyping” in perspective. The assumption of being a “privileged white girl” is totally unfair and quite frankly rude. So many times in societal interactions, we assume without even thinking. Let’s remember we are all humans with our own upbringings that no one knows excepts for you and the people associated with you.

    Liked by 1 person

  • What is the difference between having “privilege” and being “privileged?” What does McIntosh say here? Also, where do the authors say “privileged white girl” Both authors are pushing us to think about how privilege operates and how class, race, gender, sexuality not only results in “unearned advantages” but that in order to understand privilege we have to talk about intersections of race, gender, class and sexuality. We will talk more in coming days but key to think about “unearned advantage”

    Like

  • Even after reading theses two articles “white privileged” people might still have a hard time understanding the difference between “race” and “class” like the first article stated. Another thing that was said in the first article that I thought would apply to many people is when she says that it may take a person a few hours, or days, weeks, years to actually understand the meaning of white privilege and what the privileges are. I also thing that both the articles did a great job on specifying that when people talk about white privilege they aren’t saying that you are a bad person or haven’t been oppressed in any way. They don’t mean it to offend anyone but to just make people aware that if you are white these are things/privileges that you have because of the color of your skin and its not meant to be malicious of rude in any way. Good articles i enjoyed reading them.

    Like

  • Having white privilege is a very misunderstood concept, and it took me awhile to fully comprehend the meaning behind this term. Being privileged doesn’t mean I have a better childhood, a better family, and a better live than people of color. It means, personally, what was stated in the first article. I will turn on Netflix tonight seeing the majority of shows/movies having a predominantly white cast, if I get pulled over I have a lesser chance of feeling offended, picked out or stereotyped. It’s nothing that I have done in my life, it is simply a product of me being born as a white person. This is almost inevitable for a white person to avoid, or even deny with concrete facts. White privilege is merely a sense of awareness of the society surrounding them & where they stand compared to other races.

    Like

  • These articles were interesting reads, especially the first one. I was really fascinated by the perspective of someone who grew up the opposite of their racial stereotype but was able to succeed later in life despite her lesser upbringings. It was also thought-provoking when she pointed out that many people could confuse “race” with “class” because her story definitely intermixed the two stereotypes of each word. They both also helped me increase my knowledge on white privilege in new ways. I realized that because of my “white privilege” I have never given much thought to what the color of my skin does for me, it is that ingrained in our society. Meanwhile my black counterparts are struggling fights I will never understand and are more likely to think about the color or their skin and how it negatively affects them on a day to day basis. And because my understandings of this deepened, due to these articles, I will be able to help become a part of the mass movements discussed in the second article.

    Like

  • It’s amazing how when most think of “privileged” they think of race and gender. However, “privileged” can be found in a wide spread of things. Although, I think that where one sees “privileged” all depends on ones personal definition of what it truly means to be “privileged”. in this article I feel it only really covers the bias of ones opinion on what being “privileged” is. It would be interesting to note other opinions as well and compare.

    Like

    • How does this change if we think about privilege as “what everyone should experience” or what everyone is entitled to have? Does that change whether or not its an “individual opinion?

      Like

  • After reading this it really open my mind about what privileged really means. It doesn’t have to be about the skins color someone is but of how someone can be privileged. For example I am privileged to have parents pay for my college and I am not white. “There are many different types of privilege, not just skin color privilege, that impact the way people can move through the world or are discriminated against. These are all things you are born into, not things you earned, that afford you opportunities others may not have.” I agree with this, and believe that this is the right definition.

    Like

  • People that do live with white privilege don’t realize that they have it. We don’t know anything other than what our worlds have revolved around for our entire lives so its hard for some white people to even understand what the term “white privilege” even is. However I can see where if I was someone of a different ethnicity it would be a completely different case scenario as you are the one watching others be handed white privilege and you can feel in your heart that you are being treated differently.

    Like

  • Reading these articles really opened my eyes as a white female. What I think “White Privilege” means is that you have to earn things in order for you to get what you want. That’s what my dad taught me. I believe if you work hard at something, you will get it. Sure being white female you have privileges but half of us have to earn what we want; believe I know. I have worked a lot for were I am now in life, same with my parents. We just don’t things handed to us, well at least not for me and maybe other people too. I believe whether or not we are white or colored we still have the same privileges because we all work hard to get what we want.

    Like

  • These articles were interesting to read, very catchy and it flowed together nicely. I focused mainly on the description of how nobody is trying to offend you (if you are a white individual who may be privileged). I agree and disagree. I want to know whom they are talking about when they say that they are not trying to offend you. I am a white girl of privilege, who realizes it, and I have been torn down by negative comments, that were aimed strictly at trying to tell me I was undeserving of my situation(s) in life, school, job opportunities, etc. On the other hand, I have witnessed those who do not say it to offend, who say it strictly out of curiosity of if I was aware of my privileges, or just to state their opinion. I keep hearing the definition of privilege being thrown around as an unearned advantage. If my “privileges” are my situations in school, job opportunities, etc., than I disagree with that definition. Those situations are because of my hard work; I earned it. And although I did not grow up around a high poverty community, or around a lot of discrimination and racism, I have individuals I have encountered in my lifetime who had earned their advantages, and they just so happened to be of color. However, I realize that that does not go for our entire country, but I realize that my life is a “privilege”. Back to Nicholas Kristof’s article when he states, “Do people really think we take off from the same starting line”? I really believe we all start differently. We are all born into different situations. We all do not start or finish the same. We all have different obstacles, roads, narrow pathways, or even rides along the way. When I look at the word privilege, I tend to see the word luck. I was lucky to be brought into this life by the family I have. I did not win a game of lottery that should have never been played with. Everyone has their own journey with a destination they do not expect to reach tomorrow, however I like the idea they portray in this article of how we take on that journey together, and to not wave away those people who do not mean to offend you, but to tag along and conquer the journey together.

    Like

  • Kati: remember, saying that there is an advantage or that everyone is starting at same starting line or running the same race or facing the same obstacles is not a commentary on a person’s woe ethic or talents. Think about study about “value of a name.” If those with white sounding names are 50% more likely to receive a call back for a job, that is advantage. Or think Devon Pena, blocs and Latinos are more likely to live in close proximity to toxic waste facilities, which has impact on health, which of course would impact education, job, etc. Not living close to these facilities is an advantage. Living outside of food junkyards is advantage. As reading as noted, this isn’t a commentary on individuals and their talents/work ethic but the structures and contexts that we exist

    Like

  • Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

    Connecting to %s

    %d bloggers like this: